Retrofit for the future of sustainable social housing

download as PDF
Download
as PDF
The retrofit of a pair of semi-detached, 1950's "no-fines" concrete solid-walled houses. The aim is to deliver a low-tech, low-cost, zero-carbon retrofit of a traditionally hard-to-treat home, using existing technologies and traditional build techniques. The low-tech approach minimises the maintenance overhead for the landlord and in-use operation for the tenant. The design approach is to utilise the existing mass of the property, combined with super-insulation, passive solar design, energy-efficient hot water generation and mechanical ventilation, to deliver an ultra low-energy house. Remaining energy demands will be met not by on-site, building integrated renewables, but by purchasing of shares in a local community wind turbine.

Retrofit for the future ZA366J
Images Graphs Figures Description Strategies Building

Retrofit for the future of sustainable social housing : Project images

Click on image to preview full size

Front_Elevation.jpg
R4tF_potential_design_sketches_Page_01.jpg
R4tF_potential_design_sketches_Page_02.jpg
R4tF_potential_design_sketches_Page_03.jpg
R4tF_potential_design_sketches_Page_04.jpg
R4tF_potential_design_sketches_Page_05.jpg
R4tF_potential_design_sketches_Page_06.jpg
R4tF_potential_design_sketches_Page_07.jpg
R4tF_potential_design_sketches_Page_08.jpg
Rear_elevation.jpg
CO2 emissionsPrimary energy requirement
Energy target
Retrofit for the Future

Energy and fuel use

Fuel use by type
Primary energy requirement
CO2 emissions
Renewables

Measured data from renewable generation is not yet available.

Fuel use

 Pre-developmentForecastMeasured
Electricity use 3241 kWh/yr 2580 kWh/yr -
Natural gas use27153.9 kWh/yr - -
Oil use- - -
LPG use- - -
Wood use- - -
Other Fuel - - -
 Pre-developmentForecastMeasured
Primary energy requirement 468 kWh/m².yr 77 kWh/m².yr -
Annual CO₂ emissions 89 kg CO₂/m².yr 18 kg CO₂/m².yr -
Annual space heat demand - 8.63 kWh/m².yr -

Renewable energy

Electricity generationForecastMeasured
Off-site community wind turbine2580 kWh/yr -
Other Renewables Tech--
Electricity consumed by generation --
Primary energy requirement
offset by renewable generation
--
Annual CO₂ emissions
offset by renewable generation
--

Calculation and targets

Whole house energy calculation method OTHER
Other whole house calculation methodWe have used the SAP extension for Whole House but adjusted the predicted figures down in line with our evidenced experience.
Energy target Retrofit for the Future
Other energy targetsWe will deliver a zero-carbon retrofit by investing in a local community owned wind turbine to offset the remaining energy demand in the house. This is only after in-house energy demand has been minimised as much as possible through energy efficiency mea
Forecast heating load -

Airtightness

 DateResult
Pre-development air permeability test--
Final air permeability test--

Project description

StageUnder construction
Start date01 March 2010
Occupation date01 July 2010
Location Newark Nottinghamshire  England
Build typeRefurbishment
Building sectorPublic Residential
Property typeSemi-Detached
Construction typeOther
Other construction typeNo-fines concrete solid wall
Party wall constructionNo-fines concrere solid wall
Floor area 84
Floor area calculation method Treated Floor Area (PHPP)
Building certification

Project Team

OrganisationHockerton Housing Project Trading Limited
Project lead personHockerton Housing Project Trading Limited
Landlord or ClientNewark and Sherwood Homes
ArchitectHockerton Housing Project Trading Limited
Mechanical & electrical consultant
Energy consultantHockerton Housing Project Trading Limited
Structural engineer
Quantity surveyor
Consultant
Contractor

Design strategies

Planned occupancyThe houses being retrofitted are both currently occupied by tenants that have requested transfers, therefore the planned occupancy is currently not known, as new tenants, totally engaged and committed to the retrofit monitoring, will be selected during the retrofit process. However, as the houses are 3-bedroom, we envisage families of 4-6 members occupying the properties.
Space heating strategyThe existing gas-fired central heating system will be removed. Space heating demand will be minimal once the retrofit is complete, and therefore simple wall-mounted electric panel heaters in strategic locations will provide any occassional top-up space heating requirements. This is a simpler, lower maintenance and more cost-effective approach than retaining a central heating system. Additionally, as this is a retrofit for the future, aimed to make the homes future-proofed for 2050 and beyond, retaining a heating system based on a finite and non-renewable energy source, is contradictory to this aim.
Water heating strategyA high volume, super insulated temperature efficient thermal store, heated by electric immersion, will provide all the hot water demand for the house. This system is one that has been designed by HHP and successfully deployed in a number of homes we have designed and/or built. Actual hot water energy use is 40% of that predicted by SAP.
Fuel strategyThe homes will be all-electric. This future-proofs the homes for the 21st century and beyond, assuming decarbonisation of grid electricity. However, as total decarbonisation of the grid is some way off, the proposed solution to ensure the homes are zero-carbon from day one is to make a sufficient investment in a local community wind turbine to cover the predicted primary energy consumption of the houses.
Renewable energy strategyOur renewable electricity generation strategy is to invest in an off-site community wind turbine project in the local area, sizing the investment to purchase sufficient capacity to cover the predicted annual energy consumption of the homes. This strategy is a far more cost-effective approach than building integrated solutions. In addition, it removes a maintenance headache for the social landlord; it removes any operational overhead for the tenant; it generates an annual income for the social landlord to cover other maintenance costs of the home; and most importantly it is actually cash-positive, as the original investment will ultimately be returned to the social landlord.
Passive Solar strategyThis is key to our design. We are adding a 1.5 storey sun space that will harvest the passive solar energy for positive input to the house. In addition, this sun space will also shelter a significant amount of the building fabric from the external climate, acting as a buffer zone. Evidence from HHP houses shows that this buffering equates to a reduction of around 10 degrees of temperature difference between the internal and external air temperatures. As heat loss is a function of temperature difference, this reduces heat loss, and hence space heating demand, but is totally ignored by SAP. The sun spaces are thermally separated and unheated; tenant education and fused electrical circuits will be used to prevent use of plug-in heaters.
Space cooling strategyThere is no active space cooling strategy proposed. The high levels of internal mass within the insulated envelope will act as a passive space cooling system, absorbing excess natural energy flows as the air temperature rises.
Daylighting strategyDaylighting will be provided by traditional windows and glazed doors. Daylighting calculations have been carried out for all rooms in the house, and openings have been re-sized appropriately to ensure sufficient daylighting whilst minimising heat loss.
Ventilation strategyA Vent Axia Sentinel Kinetic unit will provide a whole house mechanical ventilation solution with heat recovery. This is an accredited system with a 92% heat exchange efficiency rating.
Airtightness strategy Detailing, build quality and high quality openings will ensure a high level of airtightness; design air permeability rate is 2. This will deliver a significant improvement over the current air permeability of no-fines concrete, which when tested in these homes in the early 1990s was found to be very poor.
Strategy for minimising thermal bridges The newly applied wall insulation (in a retrofitted cavity) will be taken right down to the exisitng footings and then up into the roof space in a continuous layer. Internally, the existing, uninsulated solid floor will be removed, and replaced with an insulated solid floor; the insulation layer will be placed below the new high density concrete floor, again right down to the bottom of the existing footings, and 50mm of edge insulation will be incorporated. The new openings will be fitted within plywood box liners that span the new cavity; there will be no lintels or masonary returns spanning the cavity.
Modelling strategyStandard SAP and the supplied whole house extension spreadsheet were used for modelling. Adjustments were then made to predicted figures to account for: a more efficient hot water system; sheltering provided by the sun space; heat capacity of the thermal mass.
Insulation strategyHigh levels of insulation will be applied in the floor, walls and roof. The existing solid wall will become an internal high-mass skin of a new cavity wall, with the outer brick skin being retrofitted. The cavity will be 250mm and fully filled. The existing 250mm insulation in the loft will be doubled to 500mm. The existing uninsulated solid floor will be removed, and replaced with a high mass solid floor (150mm) on top of 250mm of insulation, and incorporating 50mm of edge insulation.
Other relevant retrofit strategiesTenant education in the design principles and how to maximise the energy-efficient performance of the home.
Contextual informationNOTE: uploading of some of the design sketches has distorted them, which is why the footprint of the ground and first floors look radically different! They are both in fact 6.5m x 6.5m square.

Building services

OccupancyNULL
Space heatingNULL
Hot waterNULL
VentilationNULL
ControlsNULL
CookingNULL
LightingNULL
AppliancesNULL
Renewable energy generation systemNULL
Strategy for minimising thermal bridgesNULL

Building construction

Storeys 0
Volume -
Thermal fabric area -
Roof description NULL
Roof U-value 0.00 W/m² K
Walls description NULL
Walls U-value 0.00 W/m² K
Party walls description NULL
Party walls U-value 0.00 W/m² K
Floor description NULL
Floor U-value 0.00 W/m² K
Glazed doors description NULL
Glazed doors U-value 0.00 W/m² K -
Opaque doors description NULL
Opaque doors U-value 0.00 W/m² K -
Windows description NULL
Windows U-value 0.00 W/m² K -
Windows energy transmittance (G-value) -
Windows light transmittance -
Rooflights description NULL
Rooflights light transmittance -
Rooflights U-value 0.00 W/m² K